Wise Guys Pizza Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to Wise Guys Pizza, a delightful culinary gem nestled in the heart of South Buffalo at 1965 Seneca St. This establishment expertly marries Buffalo pride with a touch of Mafia nostalgia, creating an inviting atmosphere that captivates patrons from the moment they walk in.
The menu is a savory celebration of classic offerings. Indulge in their signature cheese and pepperoni pizzas, known for their generous cheese and sweet, tangy sauce that pairs perfectly with a crispy crust. Daily specials, such as the 30-wing combo with pizza, make for irresistible deals that keep customers coming back.
- Try their hearty subs, like the Stinger Hoagie, loaded with chopped steak and crispy chicken fingers.
- Salads such as the Chicken Finger Salad offer a refreshing complement to the rich flavors.
Every dish is crafted with fresh ingredients, ensuring a flavorful experience that satisfies both locals and newcomers alike. Prepare for a culinary adventure that embodies the spirit of Buffalo!
Salads
Chicken Souvlaki Salad
comes with pita bread
Antipasto
Julienne Salad
Chicken Finger Salad
Grilled Chicken
Chef Salad
Monday
20 - Any Specialty Pie 30 - Any 3 Whole Hot And/or Cold Subs (excludes hoagies)
Tuesday
16.99- Large pizza cheese & pepperoni
Wednesday
Any 3 Whole Hot And/or Cold Subs (excludes hoagies)
Saturday
Any 3 Whole Hot And/or Cold Subs (excludes hoagies)
Medium Cheese And Pepperoni & 10 Wings
Medium Cheese And Pepperoni Pizza & 15 Boneless Wings
Large Cheese And Pepperoni Pizza & 20 Wings
Large Cheese And Pepperoni Pizza & 50 Wings
18 X-Large Cheese And Pepperoni Pizza & 30 Wings
X-Large Cheese And Pepperoni Pizza & 15 Chicken Fingers
Sheet Cheese And Pepperoni Pizza & 50 Wings
Sheet Cheese And Pepperoni Pizza & 55 Boneless Wings
Daily Specials
Subs & Hoagies
Assorted
ham, salami, and capicola
Bacon Cheeseburger
One half pound Angus burger, crispy bacon, smothered in American cheese, lettuce and tomato.
Baked Sicilian Sub
Sausage, Bacon, Mozzarella and Parmesan. All baked on a Garlic Toast Roll with fried onions and your choice of pepper.
BLT
Capicola
Margherita capicola
Cheese
baked on request
Cheeseburger
Chicken Bacon Ranch Sub
Chicken Finger
Chicken Finger Club
Chicken Parm
Chicken Souvlaki
Ham
Sahlen's smoked ham
Ham & Turkey
Sahlen's ham & premium turkey
Hitman
sausage, capicola, ham & salami (hot sauce optional)
Italian Sausage
Meatball
Pizza
mozzarella & pepperoni
Royal Sausage & Capicola
Salami
Margherita Salami
Steak Sub
NOT Chopped
Turkey Club
Turkey Sub
Chicken Hoagie
Steak Hoagie
Sausage Hoagie
Steak & Chicken Hoagie
Steak & Sausage Hoagie
Hoagie Supreme
Includes peppers, mushrooms, spinach optional
Stinger Hoagie
chopped steak & delicious chicken fingers sauced to your liking
Jay's Steak & Bacon Hoagie
Cheeseburger Hoagie
Turkey Hoagie
Specialty Pizza Logs (4)
Honey BBQ, Loganberry BBQ, Honey Mustard, Open Pit BBQ, Honey Sesame, Dr. Pepper BBQ, Buffalo, Godfather, etc. (refer to specialty wing sauces)
Garlic Bread Sticks W/Cheese
Pizza Logs(4)
Deep Fried Mushrooms
Garlic Bread Sticks
Oven Baked Garlic Bread W/Cheese
Pretzel Sticks W/ Beer Cheese Dip (4)
French Fries (1 LB)
Shaken Fries
Choice of ranch OR bleu cheese shaken in medium sauce, smothered in mozzarella and cheddar.
Poutine Fry
Smothered in gravy and topped with cheese curds.
Steak Hoagie Fries
steak & mozzarella with mushroom/onion upon request
Pizza Fries
Pizza Sauce, cheese, pepperoni
Lemon Pepper Fries
Shaken in lemon pepper seasoning and topped with mozzarella.
Cajun Fries
Shaken in Cajun seasoning and topped with mozzarella.
Nacho Fries
Bacon & Nacho Cheese. Sour cream extra.
Garlic Parmesan Fries
Shaken in garlic sauce topped with parmesan.
Buffalo Chicken Finger Fry
Fingers are shaken in Buffalo Sauce and then smothered in mozzarella cheese.
Sides
Catering Menu
Wrap Platter
An assortment of 8 cold wraps of your choice!
Sub Platter
An assortment of 8 cold subs of your choice!
10 Large 1 Topping Pizzas
Get 10 Large 1 topping pizzas of your choice!!
10 Large Specialty Pizzas
Get 10 large specialty pizzas of your choice!!
Large Tray Souvlaki Salad
comes with two 16oz containers of your choice of dressing
Large Tray Chef Salad
comes with two 16oz containers of your choice of dressing
Large Tray Grilled Chicken Salad
comes with two 16oz containers of your choice of dressing
Large Tray AntiPasta Salad
comes with two 16oz containers of your choice of dressing
10 Lb Tray Of Potato Salad
Homemade Potato Salad
10 Lb Tray Of Macaroni Salad
Homemade Macaroni Salad
10 Lb Tray Of Cole Slaw
Homemade Cole Slaw
15 Lunch Special Bund
Your choice of 15 of our weekly lunch specials!! (Substitute any cold sub for cold wrap)
10 Lb Tray Of French Fries
10 Lbs of straight cut french fries
50 Chicken Fingers
Your choice of flavors split however many ways!! Comes with 8 Bleu cheeses and Fries NOT included!!
Tray Of Baked Penne
Homemade Baked Penne with melted Mozz cheese!!
Tray Of Baked Chicken Parm
Delicious tray of approx. 20 pieces of baked chicken parm!!
Tray Of Stuffed Shells
approx. 20 delicious home made Stuffed shells baked in the oven with Mozz cheese!!
Tray Of 2oz Meatballs With Rolls
Approx. 40 meatballs with melted Mozz cheese and 2 dozen dinner rolls!!
Tray Cannolis
25 Delicious self made Cannolis!!
12 SLICES OF Cheesecake
12 slices of Plain cheesecake!!
10 2-Liters
Your choice of any 10 2-liters we have to offer!!
10 Lbs Of Boneless Chicken Breast Marinated In Chivettas
delicious chivettas marinated chicken
Tray Of Baked Penne W/ Chicken
baked penne pasta smothered with homemade sauce and mozzarella cheese topped with delicious diced chicken breast
Tray Of Beer Cheese Mac And Cheese
amazing homemade mac and cheese made with mouth watering beer cheese
Tray Of Mashed Potatoes
Tray of potatoes mashed to perfection
Slice Of Pizza
(9) Personal
(13) Medium Cheese
(16) Large Cheese
(18) X-Large Cheese
Sheet Cheese
(14) Cauliflower Crust Pizza
Pizza
Chicken Wings
Jumbo Single (10)
Jumbo Double (20)
Jumbo Triple (30)
Jumbo Bucket (50)
Flavored Sauces For Your Wings
Dr. Pepper BBQ - Honey BBQ - Char BBQ - Hot & Spicy BBQ - Loganberry BBQ - Jerk BBQ - God Father BBQ (Jerk/Loganberry BBQ mix) - Cajun BBQ -Lemon pepper BBQ -Honey Sesame BBQ -Lemon Pepper - Honey Lemon Pepper - Honey Garlic Lemon Pepper - Jerk Lemon Pepper - Cajun Lemon Pepper Cajun (Wet or Dry) - Honey CajunHoney Mustard - Chipotle Honey Mustard - Jerk Honey MustardHoney - Honey Sesame - Honey Garlic -H -Honey Jerk Garlic Parmesan - Hot Garlic Parmesan Jamaican Jerk Chiavetta's Atomic Hot
Boneless & Fries (Single 15)
Boneless & Fries (Double 25)
Boneless & Fries (Triple 35)
Boneless & Fries (Bucket 55)
Flavored Sauces For Your Wings
Dr. Pepper BBQ - Honey BBQ - Char BBQ - Chipotle BBQ - Hot & Spicy BBQ - Loganberry BBQ - Jerk BBQ - God Father BBQ (Jerk/Loganberry BBQ mix) - Cajun BBQ -Korean BBQ -Lemon pepper BBQ -Honey Sesame BBQ -Lemon Pepper - Honey Lemon Pepper - Honey Garlic Lemon Pepper - Jerk Lemon Pepper - Cajun Lemon Pepper Cajun (Wet or Dry) - Honey CajunHoney Mustard - Chipotle Honey Mustard - Jerk Honey MustardHoney - Honey Sesame - Honey Garlic -Honey Hot -Honey Jerk Garlic Parmesan - Hot Garlic Parmesan Jamaican Jerk Chiavetta's Sweat Teriyaki Sweet Chili Atomic HotMango Habanero Kickin Bourbon
Boneless
Chicken Fingers
Chicken Fingers & Fries (5)
Chicken Fingers & Fries (10)
Chicken Fingers & Fries (22)
Flavored Sauces For Your Wings
Dr. Pepper BBQ - Honey BBQ - Char BBQ -- Hot & Spicy BBQ - Loganberry BBQ - Jerk BBQ - God Father BBQ (Jerk/Loganberry BBQ mix) - Cajun BBQ - -Lemon pepper BBQ -Honey Sesame BBQ -Lemon Pepper - Honey Lemon Pepper - Honey Garlic Lemon Pepper - Jerk Lemon Pepper - Cajun Lemon Pepper Cajun (Wet or Dry) - Honey CajunHoney Mustard - Chipotle Honey Mustard - Jerk Honey MustardHoney - Honey Sesame - Honey Garlic - -Honey Jerk Garlic Parmesan - Hot Garlic Parmesan Jamaican Jerk Chiavetta's Atomic Hot
Cannoli's
(3) delicious ricotta chocolate chips dusted with powdered sugar
Fried Dough
Smothered in butter, powdered sugar & cinnamon.Add cherry topping for 1.50
Slice Of Oreo Cake
Slice Of Cherry Cheesecake
Slice Of Plain Cheesecake
Slice Of Red Velvet Cake
Cinnamon Sticks
Desserts
Dinners
Meatball Dinner
4 hefty meatballs, garlic bread, and side salad.
Personal Antipasto & Garlic Bread With A Can Of Pop
15 Boneless Wings & Fries With A Can Of Pop
4 Pizza Logs & Fries With A Can Of Pop
Any Mini Cold Sub & Chef Salad Or Fries
Personal Souvlaki & Garlic Bread With A Can Of Pop
Medium Cheese And Pepperoni
no substitutions